Low-cost housing in South Africa – a story of fraud, corruption, and general mismanagement.

25 05 2008

By Michelle Solomon

The low-cost houses in Vukani, a district in Grahamstown’s township, are in a seriously poor condition, displaying cracking walls, loose bricks, and leaking roofs. But Vukani is not the only housing project to be in such a poor state, and all over South Africa housing projects have become the subject of often scathing news reports.

“Over the last few years, many communities have shown their growing dissent over the government’s perceived poor levels in service delivery [in housing]” (Burgoyne, 12). In Vukani, experts have attributed the dismal state of Vukani housing to the use of emerging contractors, various degrees of corruption, poor planning and monitoring on the part of Makana municipality, and so on. Burgoyne writes that “the housing strategy lacked coherency and inadequately defined the roles and responsibilities of all role players in the housing sector.” According to Burgoyne, “this has contributed to the present breakdown in delivery and confusion as to housing responsibilities” (13).

The latest version of the South African Housing Code better defines the responsibilities of the various players in the housing sector, and most importantly that of local government. In terms of health of safety for instance, the municipality must “ensure that conditions not conducive to the health and safety of the inhabitants of its area of jurisdiction are prevented or removed” (South African Housing Code). Now if we ignore all the other clauses stipulating Makana’s responsibility for the problem in Vukani, the health and safety clause is clear. When we were in Vukani, many of the 1000 houses built had loose bricks over doorways, and even walls that swung roughly 1 cm in a slight breeze – these pose clear safety risks. A mother residing in Vukani was particularly concerned that the loose bricks above her front door would fall down and fatally injure her young children.

The Media and Communication’s officer at Makana municipality denies responsibility for the problem, while the Public Services Accountability Monitor (PSAM) and other sources claim this to be false.

Similar problems have arisen nation-wide. In an online story published by City Press, reporters state that a common problem with low-cost housing in several provinces is “shoddy workmanship” (Dumisane Lubisi, Jackie Mapiloko, Makhudu Sefara). In the Eastern Cape’s case, the poor quality of the houses may be attributed to several factors, but Lubisi, Mapiloko and Sefara point out a crucial error on the part of the provincial government. “The province elected to build a 40m² house using a conditional grant allowance which was based on a 30m² unit as the national norm,” Phumlani Mndolomba of the Eastern Cape Housing Department is quoted as saying (Lubisi et al).

The problem of poor workmanship of housing projects has also occurred in Mpumalanga, where the province had to destroy a housing project amounting to R9.5-million after is was discovered that “the developer had used “weak bricks” to build the 427 units” (Lubisi et al).

Mamelodi, a housing project on the periphery of Tshwane, Guateng, has also been declared of an inferior quality. “The more than 600 houses constructed to date are so defective that the Tshwane metro council refuses to issue occupation certificates and allow them to move in”, writes Waldner in City Press. Apparently, Tshwane metro did not approve any of the houses in Mamelodi’s Extension 22 because the “poor workmanship and materials used do not meet the minimum standards set by national building regulations” states council spokesperson Antoinette Mostert.

Ndivhuwo Mabaya, national housing department spokesperson, has stated that in cases where houses were of poor quality or where developers had disappeared after being paid, government would track down the developers and recover the money (Lubisi et al). In our investigation however, allegations were made that often beneficiaries of these sub-standard houses are intimidated by those responsible for the problem, including contractors and local government, and so they do not have a space to voice the problems with their homes. In Mamelodi, some houses were allegedly built on crooked foundations, the windows have no glass, and there are no storm-water pipes (Waldner). The latter of these is also evident in the houses of Vukani, and because the project is based on a slope, flooding and winter rains are potentially very hazardous to the safety of Vukani residents.

Delmas, Mpumalanga, has also been the site of an even worse standard of low-cost housing. Here, roughly 500 houses are subject to poor and defective sewerage systems, among other things. Mokoena writes that roughly 500 houses in Delpark Extension 2 are “surrounded by a trench of dirty, stinking water, which contains faeces”. There are also “leaking water pipes, roofs, drains and toilets. Others have no window panes, doors and sewer pipes” according to Mokoena.

“In some parts of the area, the drainage system cannot function properly, causing spillage of water and faeces into some of the houses, while in other areas there are no toilets, and residents are forced to walk for about 15 minutes to the veld to relieve themselves.” (Mokoena)

The national housing project has aimed to provide the many South Africans living in informal settlements (corrugated iron shacks) with “adequate housing”. In the South African constitution, it is a right to have such housing, but to the dismay of low-cost housing beneficiaries nation-wide, housing departments are not even meeting national standards for these housing. And we fail dismally and completely on an international scale.

Relevant links:

South African Housing Code; Part 2; Chapter 2.3 – “Role and functions of local government”

http://www.housing.gov.za/Content/The%20Housing%20Code/Part%202/Part%202%20-%20Chapter%202.htm#2.3

Burgoyne. “Factors affecting housing delivery in South Africa”.

http://209.85.175.104/search?q=cache:olUi3UnzOJ8J:ir.sun.ac.za/dspace/bitstream/10019/759/1/Burgoyne,%2BML.pdf+%22RDP+housing%22,+%22south+africa%22,+%22poor+quality%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=12&gl=za

Dumisane Lubisi, Jackie Mapiloko, Makhudu Sefara. City Press. “R2bn housing scandal”.

http://www.news24.com/City_Press/News/0,,186-187_2151358,00.html

Mariechen Waldner. City Press. “Shack dwellers rue defective homes”.

http://www.news24.com/City_Press/News/0,,186-187_2085334,00.html

Matefu Mokoena. City Press. “Mayor slammed over poor-quality houses”.

http://www.news24.com/City_Press/News/0,,186-187_1094096,00.html

 

Advertisements

Actions

Information

17 responses

29 10 2008
BSM Group

Why does there always have to be fraud and corruption in South Africa, its just so sad that instead of just doing good there have to a be negativity behind it too.

19 11 2008
moladi

moladi, a South African Company and International supplier for the past 22 years, the pioneer of a one-step casting process for the construction of homes,”…Simply cast a whole house in a day, employing unskilled labour, reducing time, waste and cost, eliminating chasing for plumbing and electrical pipe work, plastering and beam filling, resulting in a wall stronger than brick. A cost effective, holistic design and build technology that far outweighs poorly designed costly concrete-block and masonry structures…

Lack of resources, insufficient funds, skills shortage, time constraints, work flow control and waste are key challenges embodied in affordable housing shortages. Our technology addresses these issues and this is why individuals and organizations recognize moladi as the solution to housing needs throughout the world. We supply technology and support transfer of know-how by means of on site training.

But no, lets build conventional and rebuild in five years and spend more of SA tax payers money!!!!!

20 11 2008
“Minister of Toilets” « Africa is a Country

[…] I could not help make the connection between “Minister of Toilets” and “toilets in the veld.” Inside South Africa that reminds South Africans of sub-standard state-led housing developments (usually plagued by corrupt practices) for South Africa’s black poor, first under Apartheid and since 1994. […]

3 01 2009
moladi

Now i dont feel so lonely! Thouche, this is what we are up against for many years and want to see change. Would like to link to your site? OK?

Regards
moladi
http://www.moladi.com or http://www.moladi.net

13 05 2009
rubern

Hi there……due to our gorv. we vote for many times but he only made one promice but he doesn’n follow it.I here in Cape Town,the place named Khayelitsha.ever since we lived i shacks
from 1992 till now.we still on the situation even now.a worse thing there’s no toilets and power;worried for the kids because there no place to help themselves and the envernoment they living under coused them to attend clinics every short period of time.
we did put a claim and figth to get housing or a better place to live but even now no respond from our gorv.
we just asking for help not demmanding.

21 07 2009
DIANE

michelle, can i please use the photo at the start of this comment for a poster i’m producing to advocate and ‘end to apartheid planning’. will be used to advertise an architectural student competition.
i will acknowledge by placing your name on the page

thanks

20 08 2010
TALISA

What can we expect with these little kaffirs in south africa. they do not know what they are doing and are clearly apointed in the wrong positiona

20 08 2010
kerry

I agree with Talisa although the term is a bit harsh. The wrong people are appointed in the wrong positions. they often misuse their power and steal our money and spend it on the most unessecary things. if they take our tax for crap then i tthink we should get some of that crap for our enjoyment too.

8 08 2012
mens fitness

Awesome post. Check out my website to get more info about bodybuilding,
if you like.

28 03 2013
the pirate bay.org telugu

Much is claimed and discussing the crimes committed
by the aborigines from the white man, nevertheless it needs to be
remembered that this blacks were given great provocation.

Not only does a digger are aware that it is extremely possible he may
look for a lots of gold with little or no trouble, but, worse still, he
knows he or she work very difficult without getting any gold at all.
Just because your swelling decreases a bit responding towards the diuretic does not always mean you are getting better.

16 04 2013
Discover More

I have recently started a web site, the information you provide
on this website has helped me greatly. Thank you for all
of your time & work.

20 06 2013
hultquist earrings

Great post.

23 11 2013
On predictability. The everyday struggles of shack dwellers in South Africa | Abahlali baseMjondolo

[…] they are frequently sub-standard, unsustainably located, and corruptly distributed. Another trend is just as troubling: in law, shack dwellers cannot be evicted without a court […]

3 12 2013
16 04 2014
car shipping via train

It is not my first time to pay a visit this web site, i am visiting this website dailly and obtain good data from
here all the time.

28 06 2014
interesting things

Great web site you have here.. It’s hard to find high quality writing like yours these days.

I truly appreciate people like you! Take care!!

7 11 2014
On predictability. The everyday struggles of shack dwellers in South Africa | Democracy in Africa

[…] year. But where houses are delivered, they are frequently sub-standard, unsustainably located, and corruptly distributed. Another trend is just as troubling: in law, shack dwellers cannot be evicted without a court […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




%d bloggers like this: